Los Angeles, one of the most expensive housing markets in the country, has implemented a new tax called the “mansion tax” as part of its effort to fund affordable housing and homelessness programs. Starting April 1, Measure ULA will take effect, imposing a 4% cut on all home sales ranging from $5 million to $10 million, and 5.5% on sales exceeding $10 million. Supporters believe that it could raise around $900 million annually to help tackle the city’s critical homeless crisis. However, some real estate brokers and developers have expressed concerns that this new tax would discourage new construction and hurt the market.
The Scope of the Mansion Tax
The ‘mansion tax’ will take a 4% cut of home sales between $5 million and $10 million, while anything above $10 million will be charged 5.5%. This policy is expected to affect 457 mansions in Los Angeles worth more than $5 million. The money generated by this policy will be substantial enough for the city’s affordable housing and tenant assistance programs. According to advocates, this tax would slow down investment on mega-mansions, which often remain vacant when people live on the streets.
Opposition from Real Estate Interests
Real estate interests are fighting this policy in court, arguing that it violates California’s constitution. They fear that it will adversely affect new construction projects and discourage people from buying luxury houses in Los Angeles’s lucrative property market. The additional tax imposed along with other taxes and fees involved in selling property may bring the total tax rate up to 11%, a significant amount.
Encouraging Deadline Deals
As the deadline approaches for imposing the new tax, many real estate agencies have been offering deadline deals that include bonus commissions, credits, not to mention luxury car offers to entice buyers. Some properties that might have been priced at a hair above $5 million are now being marketed around $4.9 million, just under the tax cutoff, with buyers agreeing to pay the property’s closing costs instead of the sellers.
Contending Views on the “Mansion Tax”
The term “mansion tax” used to describe Measure ULA is contested in the city, as it also applies to commercial real estate deals, not only luxury residential projects. Moreover, some argue that a $5 million house in Los Angeles would no longer be classified as a mansion. Meanwhile, Scott Tamkin, a real estate agent claims that true luxury properties in LA now begin at around $10 million. California’s housing market has become fiercely competitive over recent years, and the rise of the city as a global financial center has further transformed its pricing.
Revenue Generation and its Uses
Initially expected to raise almost $1 billion annually for Los Angeles, the ‘mansion tax’ may now produce around $672 million each year. Over the next decade, advocates estimate that this revenue could fund 26,000 affordable housing units and offer tens of thousands of residents with emergency rental assistance, income support and legal assistance for fighting evictions.
Final Thoughts
While there have been some concerns regarding new construction projects and overall market activity post-implementation of this policy, a 2022 UCLA study suggests that progressive growth could be sufficiently impactful. Despite initial opposition from certain interest groups, Los Angeles aims to use Measure ULA as a tool for building both sustainable affordable housing options and addressing homelessness within its communities.
Image Source: Wikimedia Commons
