Trotter Highlights NFL’s Struggle with Diversity and Inclusion
NFL Media has fired Jim Trotter, a black journalist who questioned the league’s lack of diversity in coaching and front-office positions. Trotter was critical of the NFL’s commitment to diversity and equity, as well as its treatment of women in the league-owned network and website. Trotter’s questions to NFL commissioner Roger Goodell were asked because he had no other option to hold the league accountable for their actions. The NFL did not respond to Trotter’s questions about the persistently homogeneous hiring practices. The league is not committed to diversity and is not interested in being questioned by journalists who hold them accountable for their actions.
Trotter’s Departure Highlights Lack of Diversity in NFL Newsroom
Trotter’s contract with NFL Network was not renewed after he raised concerns about the lack of diversity in the newsroom. Other NFL Network employees also announced being let go, possibly due to mass layoffs. Trotter’s departure is concerning as he held the NFL accountable on issues of diversity. The NFL claims 58% of full-time employees hired in 2022 were people of color, but there are still no Black senior managers in the newsroom and no full-time Black person on the news desk. Trotter argues that people with similar cultural and life experiences as the players should have a say in how they are covered. Goodell denies being involved in the decision not to renew Trotter’s contract.
Possible Lawsuit by Former NFL Media Employee Against NFL
Former NFL Media employee Jim Trotter may sue the NFL for the termination of his employment. The absence of clear language compelling Trotter to allow any and all claims to be resolved in the forum of the league’s choosing points to a process that would happen in open court. This would result in much more information being available to the media and the public. The case would be resolved with a trial during which all relevant witnesses would testify, and a jury would eventually make a decision on whether Trotter’s termination was influenced by the questions and concerns he raised regarding diversity, equity, and inclusion. The NFL usually prefers private arbitration controlled by NFL Commissioner Roger Goodell when being sued, but Trotter’s contract does not contain an arbitration clause. It is surprising that the NFL doesn’t insert such clauses into contracts signed by members of NFL Media, as it is a common term in coaching contracts. Trotter’s public comments suggest that litigation is coming, as he believes his questions to Commissioner Roger Goodell played a role in his termination.
Trotter’s departure underscores the NFL’s struggle with diversity and inclusion. While the league claims to be committed to diversity, its actual hiring practices suggest otherwise. The league has been sued by three black coaches for alleged racist hiring practices and exiled a black quarterback for protesting against police brutality. Furthermore, NFL-owned media operations are often extensions of team public relations offices that focus on “exclusive” interviews and avoid critical reporting.
Trotter’s firing is troubling as it sends a message to other journalists that they cannot hold the NFL accountable for its actions. Those who speak out on issues like diversity and inclusion could face retaliation from the league or be let go under vague circumstances similar to Trotter’s departure.
Trotter’s fight for greater diversity in NFL media should serve as an inspiration to others in positions of power who can make real changes within their organizations for greater inclusivity. For its part, the NFL may need to take stronger and more concrete steps to demonstrate its commitment to equity, diversity and inclusion.
Image Source: Wikimedia Commons
