Huge technology industry executives and academics have signed an open letter calling for a pause on large, open experiments with Artificial Intelligence (AI) systems. The signatories include influential technology leaders such as Elon Musk, Steve Wozniak, and IBM chief scientist Grady Booch.
The Need for a Pause
The call for a pause comes at a time when companies researching AI are in an out-of-control race to develop and deploy more powerful digital minds. Advanced AI has been a concern for science fiction authors for decades. However, now more technologists are warning about the need for regulation of the industry.
The letter requests a minimum pause of at least six months to prevent potentially apocalyptic scenarios, including the loss of control of civilization. If a pause cannot be enacted quickly, governments should step in and institute a moratorium.
Testing on the General Public
Companies like Google, Microsoft, and Snapchat are effectively testing new technology on the general public without considering broader consequences and how they could disrupt labor markets. While some ethicists have criticized the letter for focusing on theoretical, eventual harms from AI, others have pointed out major concerns. These include the potential for large numbers of creative workers to be put out of work and the need for regulation and enforcement in the here and now.
Concerns about Training Powerful AI Systems
Tech leaders, professors, and researchers have called for a pause in training the most powerful AI systems for at least six months due to risks to society and humanity. Advanced AI could represent a profound change in the history of life on Earth and should be planned and managed with care. Without proper planning and management, AI labs are engaged in an out-of-control race to develop ever more powerful AI systems that no one can understand, predict or reliably control.
The Future of Life Institute published the letter, which was backed by Elon Musk. OpenAI recently announced the development of GPT4, a more powerful version of the technology behind the viral AI chatbot ChatGPT. This chatbot can draft lawsuits, pass standardized exams, and build websites from sketches.
Risks Posed by AI
Language models like GPT4 can compete with humans in a growing range of tasks and could be used for automating jobs and spreading misinformation. There are concerns regarding AI tools’ potential for biased responses, spreading misinformation, impacting consumer privacy, and upending professions. They also enable student cheating and shift our relationship with technology.
The letter suggests that if a pause is not put in place soon, governments should step in and create a moratorium. Some governing agencies in China, EU and Singapore have previously introduced early versions of AI governance frameworks.
Profit-driven Race
The signatories expressed concern that OpenAI, Microsoft, and Google have begun a profit-driven race to develop and release new AI models as quickly as possible. The pace of change and investment in AI are significant, with Microsoft pouring $10 billion into OpenAI and using its AI in Bing and other applications.
Google has previously created powerful language models but chose not to release them until this year due to ethical concerns. The attention around ChatGPT has fueled an arms race among tech companies to develop similar AI tools, with OpenAI, Microsoft, and Google at the forefront.
Final Thoughts
The signatories of the letter want to make sure that the pause is “public and verifiable” involving all those working on advanced AI models like GPT4. They raised concerns about the distant prospect of AI systems that could replace humans and remake civilization.
In conclusion, this call for a pause is a significant move towards more careful scrutiny of AI systems’ development. It’s an attempt to encourage both industry leaders and governments worldwide to prioritize their attention to the consequences of developing AI technology.
Image Source: Wikimedia Commons
